M 24/336
LiveMining LeaseCity of Kalgoorlie-BoulderBroad Arrow M.F. District
Area
900.4ha
Expires
Jan 2032
in 5 years
WAMEX reports
105
WA median is 53
Report drilling
68
of 105 reports
Register summary
- Holder
- Shine Resources Pty Ltd
- Local government
- City of Kalgoorlie-Boulder
- Application received
- 20 July 1989
- Commenced
- 11 Jan 1990
- Expiry
- 10 Jan 2032
- Term
- 21 Years (Renewed)
Exploration history on this ground
105 historical WAMEX exploration reports intersect M 24/336: 27 report geochemistry or sampling, 73 include a digital data package.
When this ground was worked · 103 of 105 reports dated
11970s
31980s
221990s
302000s
442010s
32020s
Most recent reports
| Report | Year | Operator | Project | On this ground | Title |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A123941 | 2020 | Shine Resources Pty Ltd | Chameleon | <1% | Chameleon M29/428 Annual Report for the period ending 8/4/2020 |
| A125389 | 2020 | Bardoc Gold Limited | Aphrodite | <1% | C24/2008 Combined Annual Report for the period ending 30/06/2020 |
| A122945 | 2020 | Shine Resources Pty Ltd | Chameleon | 5.1% | Annual Technical Report, Chameleon & Scotia Projects C81/2019 for the period ending 09/03/2020, M24/00336, E29 |
| A119304 | 2019 | Shine Resources Pty Ltd | Scotia | 100% | Annual Technical Report Scotia Project M24/00336 for the period 11 January 2018 to 10 January 2019 |
| A120059 | 2019 | Torian Resources Limited | Bardoc | <1% | Bardoc Project P24/5024 Annual Report for the period 3 January 2018 to 2 January 2019 |
100 more reports
| A120068 | 2019 | Torian Resources Limited | Bardoc | <1% | Bardoc Project P24/5025 Annual Report for the period 4 January 2018 to 3 January 2019 |
| A121047 | 2019 | Bardoc Gold Limited | Aphrodite | 32% | Final Report Exploration Licence E24/186 Aphrodite Gold Project for the period ended 15/07/2019 |
| A121447 | 2019 | Bardoc Gold Limited | Aphrodite | <1% | Aphrodite Gold Project C24/2008 Combined Annual Report for the period 1 July 2018 to 30 June 2019, M24/00649, |
| A121501 | 2019 | Torian Resources Ltd | Bardoc | <1% | Bardoc Project P24/5082 Annual Report For the Period 4 January 2018 to 3 January 2019 |
| A121527 | 2019 | Torian Resources Ltd | Bardoc | <1% | Bardoc Project P24/5031 Annual Report for the period 30 June 2018 to 1 July 2019 |
| A119347 | 2019 | Shine Resources Pty Ltd | Chameleon | 1.4% | Annual Technical Report, Chameleon Project E29/00661 for the period 15 January 2018 to 14 January 2019 |
| A118059 | 2018 | Aphrodite Gold Limited | Aphrodite | 13% | Aphrodite Gold Project C24/2008 Combined Annual Report for the period 01/07/2017 - 30/06/2018, M24/00720, M24/ |
| A115953 | 2018 | Shine Resources Pty Ltd | Chameleon | 6.5% | Annual Technical Report, Combined Reporting C589/1994, Scotia Project for the period 2 October 2016 to 1 Octob |
| A114835 | 2017 | Aphrodite Gold Limited | Aphrodite | 13% | Combined Annual Report 2017 Aphrodite Gold C24/2008 For the Period 1 July 2016 to 30 June 2017, E24/00186, M2 |
| A115470 | 2017 | Minotaur Gold Solutions Pty Ltd | Scotia | 6.4% | Scotia Project C589/1994 Annual Technical Report for the period 02/10/2016 - 01/10/2017, E29/00661, M24/00336, |
| A109966 | 2016 | Aphrodite Gold Limited | Aphrodite | 13% | Aphrodite Gold C24/2008 Annual Report for the period For the Period 1 July 2015 to 30 June 2016, E24/00186, M |
| A110088 | 2016 | Minotaur Gold Solutions Limited | Scotia | <1% | Final Surrender Report, Scotia Project C598/1994 Final Surrender Report for the period 15/02/1989 - 31/05/2016 |
| A110569 | 2016 | Minotaur Gold Solutions Limited | Scotia | 6.4% | Annual Technical Report, Combined Reporting C589/1994, Scotia Project For the Period 2 October 2015 to 1 Octob |
| A104430 | 2015 | Excelsior Gold Limited; Minara Resources Pty Ltd | Scotia | <1% | Annual Report Scotia Project P24/4084 for the period 9 November 2013 to 8 November 2014 |
| A106788 | 2015 | Aphrodite Gold Limited | Aphrodite | 13% | Aphrodite Gold Project Combined Annual Report For the Period 1 July 2014 to 30 June 2015, E24/00186, M24/00649 |
| A105852 | 2015 | Minotaur Exploration Ltd | Goongarrie | 1.4% | Partial Surrender Report E29/661 Goongarrie Project for the period 15/01/2009 to 14/01/2015 |
| A107605 | 2015 | Minotaur Exploration Ltd | Scotia - Goongarrie | 5.2% | Scotia Goongarrie Project C589/1994 Combined Annual Report for period to 1st October 2015, E29/661, E29/719, M |
| A100580 | 2014 | Minara Resources Pty Ltd | Scotia | <1% | Annual Report, Scotia Project, Tenement P24/4075 for the period 9 November 2012 to 8 November 2013 |
| A100581 | 2014 | Minara Resources Pty Ltd | Scotia | <1% | Annual Report, Scotia Project, Tenement P24/4076 for the period 9 November 2012 to 8 November 2013 |
| A100589 | 2014 | Minara Resources Pty Ltd | Scotia | <1% | Annual Report, Scotia Project, Tenement P24/4084 for the period 9 November 2012 to 8 November 2013 |
| A103461 | 2014 | Aphrodite Gold Ltd | Aphrodite | 13% | Aphrodite Project, Annual Report for the period 01/07/2013 to 30/06/2014, M24/662, 649, 681, 720 & 779; E24/18 |
| A104421 | 2014 | Excelsior Gold Limited; Minara Resources Pty Ltd | Scotia | <1% | Annual Report, Scotia Project P24/4075 for the period 9 November 2013 to 8 November 2014 |
| A104422 | 2014 | Minara Resources Pty Ltd | Scotia | <1% | Annual Report Scotia Project P24/4076 for the period 9 November 2013 to 8 November 2014 |
| A104302 | 2014 | Minotaur Gold Solutions Limited | Scotia Goongarrie | 5.8% | ANNUAL REPORT SCOTIA GOONGARRIE PROJECT NORTH COOLGARDIE MINERAL FIELD, WESTERN AUSTRALIA FOR THE PERIOD 2nd O |
| A96203 | 2013 | Excelsior Gold Limited; Minara Resources Pty Ltd | Scotia | <1% | Scotia Project, Annual Report for the period 9th November 2011 to 8th November 2012, P24/4075. |
| A96204 | 2013 | Excelsior Gold Limited; Minara Resources Pty Ltd | Scotia | <1% | Scotia Project, Annual Report for the period 9th November 2011 to 8th November 2012, P24/4076. |
| A96212 | 2013 | Excelsior Gold Limited; Minara Resources Pty Ltd | Scotia | <1% | Scotia Project, Annual Report for the period 9th November 2011 to 8th November 2012, P24/4084. |
| A99394 | 2013 | Aphrodite Gold Ltd | Aphrodite | <1% | Aphrodite Project, Annual Report for the period 01/07/2012 to 30/06/2013, M24/662, 720, 779, 649 & 681. [C24/2 |
| A100440 | 2013 | Minotaur Exploration Ltd | Scotia Goongarrie | 5.8% | Annual Report Scotia Goongarrie Project for the period 2 October 2012 to 1 October 2013 |
| A96326 | 2012 | Scotia Nickel Pty Ltd | Scotia - Goongarrie | 4.3% | Scotia - Goongarrie Project, Annual Report for the period 2nd October 2011 to 1st October 2012, M24/279 & 336; |
| A92327 | 2012 | Minara Resources Ltd | Scotia | <1% | Annual Technical Report for the Period 9 November 2010 to 8 November 2011 for P24/4084 |
| A92319 | 2012 | Minara Resources Ltd | Scotia | <1% | Annual Technical Report for the Period 9 November 2010 to 8 November 2011 for P24/4076 |
| A94954 | 2012 | Aphrodite Gold Ltd | Aphrodite | <1% | Combined Annual Report C24/2008 Mining Leases M24/649, M24/662, M24/681, M24/720, and M24/779, Aphrodite Gold |
| A92318 | 2012 | Minara Resources Ltd | Scotia | <1% | Annual Technical Report for the Period 9 November 2010 to 8 November 2011 for P24/4075 |
| A92829 | 2012 | Scotia Nickel Ltd | Lake Goongarrie | 17% | FINAL SURRENDER REPORT, ON THE LAKE GOONGARRIE, TENEMENT EL24/123, FOR THE PERIOD TO 2 SEPTEMBER 2011 |
| A88813 | 2011 | Minara Resources Ltd | Scotia | <1% | P24/4075 Scotia, Annual Technical Report for P24/4075, 9 November 2009 to 8 November 2010 |
| A88814 | 2011 | Minara Resources Ltd | Scotia | <1% | Annual Technical Report for P24/4076, Report Period: 9 November 2009 to 8 November 2010 |
| A91343 | 2011 | Aphrodite Gold Ltd | Aphrodite | <1% | Combined Annual Report C24/2008 Mining Leases M24/649, M24/662, M24/681, M24/720, and M24/779, Aphrodite Gold |
| A88822 | 2011 | Minara Resources Ltd | Scotia | <1% | Annual Technical Report for P24/4084, 9 November 2009 to 8 November 2010 |
| A92233 | 2011 | Scotia Nickel Pty Ltd | Scotia -Goongarrie | 4.3% | ANNUAL REPORT SCOTIA GOONGARRIE PROJECT FOR THE PERIOD 2 OCTOBER 2010 TO 1 OCTOBER 2011 NORTH COOLGARDIE MINER |
| A88170 | 2010 | Aphrodite Gold Ltd | Aphrodite | <1% | Combined Annual Report C24/2008 Aphrodite Gold Project for Period 1 July 2009 to 30 June 2010, M24/649, M24/6 |
| A88646 | 2010 | Breakaway Resources Ltd | Scotia - Goongarrie | 3.2% | ANNUAL REPORT SCOTIA GOONGARRIE PROJECT FOR THE PERIOD 2 OCTOBER 2009 TO 1 OCTOBER 2010, C589/1994 |
| A84804 | 2009 | Apex Minerals Nl | Aphrodite | <1% | EXPLORATION COMBINED ANNUAL REPORT C24/2008 Aphrodite Mining Licences M24/662, M24/720, M24/779, M24/649 and M |
| A85741 | 2009 | Scotia Nickel Ltd | Scotia Goongarrie | 2.8% | Annual report Scotia Goongarrie Project for the period 2 October 2008 to 1 October 2009, North Coolgardie Mine |
| A77427 | 2008 | Apex Minerals Nl | Aphrodite | <1% | Exploration Combined Annual Report C68/1996 Aphrodite Exploration Licence E29/131 Prospecting Licence P24/3130 |
| A79261 | 2008 | Apex Minerals Nl | Aphrodite | <1% | EXPLORATION COMBINED ANNUAL REPORT C24/2008 Aphrodite Exploration Licence E29/131 Mining Licences M24/662, M24 |
| A77228 | 2008 | Scotia Nickel Ltd | Lake Goongarrie | 2.8% | ANNUAL REPORT ON THE LAKE GOONGARRIE PROJECT FOR THE PERIOD 2 OCTOBER 2006 TO 1 OCTOBER 2007 Combined Reportin |
| A79577 | 2008 | Scotia Nickel Ltd | Lake Goongarrie | 17% | PARTIAL SURRENDER REPORT ON THE LAKE GOONGARRIE TENEMENT E24/123 FOR THE PERIOD TO 23 MAY 2008 NORTH COOLGARDI |
| A80528 | 2008 | Breakaway Resources Ltd | LAKE GOONGARRIE | 2.8% | 2008 ANNUAL TECHNICAL REPORT ON THE LAKE GOONGARRIE PROJECT FOR THE PERIOD 2 OCTOBER 2007 TO 1 OCTOBER 2008 NO |
| A74355 | 2007 | Barrick (Kanowna) Ltd | Scotia | <1% | BTZ Scotia Project Annual Report , 01/01/2006 - 31/12/2006 C68/1996, E24/74, E29/131, P24/31130, P24/3193 and |
| A71933 | 2006 | Placer Dome Asia Pacific Ltd | Scotia | <1% | BTZ (Bardoc Tectonic Zone) Scotia Project, Annual Report, 01/01/2005 - 31/12/2005, Combined Reporting No. C68 |
| A73987 | 2006 | Breakaway Resources Ltd | Lake Goongarrie | 3.1% | Annual Report on the Lake Goongarrie Project for the Period 2 October 2005 to 1 October 2006, Combined Reporti |
| A71322 | 2005 | Scotia Nickel Ltd | Lake Goongarrie | 3.5% | Annual Report on the Lake Goongarrie Project for the period 1 October 2004 to 30 September 2005, North Coolgar |
| A70051 | 2005 | Placer Dome Asia Pacific Ltd | Scotia Dam | <1% | Annual report for the period 01/01/04 - 31/12/04 BTZ Scotia Project 8510, C68/1996, E24/74, E29/131, P24/3130 |
| A70727 | 2005 | Placer Dome Asia Pacific Ltd | Scotia | <1% | BTZ Scotia project, Partial surrender report, Tenement E29/131, 17 June 1991 to 24 March 2005 (Project No. 851 |
| A69525 | 2004 | Scotia Nickel Ltd | Lake Goongarrie | 3.5% | Annual Report on the Lake Goongarrie Project for the period 1 October 2003 to 30 September 2004 C589/1994 E29/ |
| A66516 | 2003 | Scotia Nickel Ltd | Bardoc Lake Goongarrie | <1% | Annual Technical Report 1st Nov 2001 to 31st Oct 2002 Bardoc Lake Goongarrie Project C589/2002: E29/144, 162 a |
| A66134 | 2003 | Placer Dome Asia Pacific Ltd | Scotia | <1% | Annual Report 01/01/2002 - 31/12/2002 BTZ Scotia Project C68/1996: E24/74, E29/131, P24/3109-13, P24/3114-17, |
| A67088 | 2003 | Placer Dome Asia Pacific Ltd | Scotia | <1% | BTZ Scotia Project, Surrender Report, 10/05/1993-13/06/2003, P24/3123, 3137-3138, 29/07/1993-13/06/2003, P24/3 |
| A68163 | 2003 | Scotia Nickel Ltd | Lake Goongarrie | 4.1% | Annual Report on the Lake Goongarrie Project for the period 1 October 2002 to 30 September 2003, E29/144, E 29 |
| A66544 | 2003 | Scotia Nickel Ltd | Scotia | 58% | Bardoc Group Scotia Project, Annual Technical Report 15th Feb 2002 to 14th Feb 2003, Tenements:M24/279 and M24 |
| A65158 | 2002 | Auriongold Exploration Pty Ltd | Woodcutters | 2.9% | Woodcutters Project Surrender Report 13/05/1996 - 12/05/2002 E29/264 Mineral Field Menzies Project Number 18-1 |
| A64582 | 2002 | Wmc Resources Ltd | Scotia | 58% | 'Scotia Project' C251/1995 (M24/279 AND M24/336) Annual Technical Report for period 15 February 2001 To 14 Feb |
| A61508 | 2001 | Wmc Resources Ltd | Lake Goongarrie | <1% | The Lake Goongarrie JV Project E29/144, 162, 170. Annual Technical Report for the Period 1 October 1999 to 30 |
| A63910 | 2001 | Wmc Resources Ltd | Lake Goongarrie | <1% | The Lake Goongarrie JV Project exploration licences 29/144, 29/162 & 29/170 Annual Technical Report for period |
| A63888 | 2001 | Wmc Resources Ltd | Scotia | 58% | Annual Technical Report for period 15 February 2000 to 14 February 2001 'Scotia Project' C251/1995 (M24/279 an |
| A61978 | 2001 | Kundana Gold Pty Ltd | Scotia | <1% | Combined Annual Report for Scotia Project 01/01/2000 to 31/12/2000 E24/74, E24/102, E29/131, E29/395, P24/3109 |
| A59711 | 2000 | Gutnick Resources Nl | Woodcutters Dam- Scotia East | 2.9% | Woodcutters Dam- Scotia East Pproject, Partial Surrender Report for the period 13th May 1996 to 13th October 1 |
| A59882 | 2000 | Goldfields Exploration Pty Ltd | Scotia | <1% | Combined Annual Report for the Scotia Project, 01/01/1999 to 31/12/1999, E24/74, E29/131, P24/3109-3117, 3121 |
| A59933 | 2000 | Wmc Resources Ltd | Lake Goongarrie | <1% | Annual Technical Report for Lake Goongarrie JV Project, E29/ 144,162,170, 1/10/1998 to 30/09/1999. |
| A60562 | 2000 | Wmc Resources Ltd | Scotia | 58% | Scotia Project, C251/1995, M24/279,336, Coolgardie, Mineral Field, Western Australia, Annual Technical Report |
| A63178 | 2000 | Centaur Mining & Exploration Ltd | Woodcutters | 1.4% | M24/615-616; P24/3367- 3376, 3623; E24/82, 264, Woodcutters Project, Annual Report for the Period 16 October |
| A57288 | 1999 | Centaur Mining & Exploration Ltd | Woodcutters | 1.4% | Joint Annual Report C293/1997- Woodcutters, Exploration Licences: E24/82, E29/264, Prospecting Licences: P24 |
| A57387 | 1999 | Goldfields Exploration Pty Ltd | Scotia | <1% | Scotia Project, Annual Report 01/01/98 - 31/12/98 E29/131, E24/74, P24/3109-3117, 3121, 3123, 3137-3138, P24/ |
| A58095 | 1999 | Wmc Resources Ltd | Scotia | 58% | Scotia Project - M24/279, 336 Coolgardie Mineral Field W.A. 15/02/98 - 14/02/99 |
| A59404 | 1999 | Centaur Mining & Exploration Ltd | Woodcutters | 1.4% | Annual Report for the period 16 October 1998 to 15 October 1999, E24/82, E29/264; M24/615-616; P24/3367-3376 |
| A53994 | 1998 | Wmc Resources Ltd | Lake Goongarrie | <1% | Annual Technical Report - Lake Goongarrie JV Project 01/10/1996-30/09/1997. E29/144,162,170. (Kalgoorlie 1:250 |
| A55076 | 1998 | Wmc Resources Ltd | Lake Goongarrie | 1.9% | Lake Goongarrie Project, Partial Surrender Report for the period 05/05/1993 to 13/03/1998, E29/162. [C589/19 |
| A57081 | 1998 | Wmc Resources Ltd | Lake Goongarrie | <1% | Lake Goongarrie JV Project 01/10/97 - 30/09/98 E29/144, 162, 170 |
| A54003 | 1998 | Goldfields Exploration Pty Ltd | Scotia Dam | <1% | Scotia Project. Annual report for period 01/01/97-31/12/97. |
| A55188 | 1998 | Wmc Resources Ltd | Scotia | 58% | Scotia Project, M24/279 and M24/336 Coolgardie Mineral Field W.A. WMC Resources Annual Technical Report 15/02/ |
| A51289 | 1997 | Wmc Resources Ltd | Scotia | 58% | Kambalda Nickel Operations 'Scotia Project' Coolgardie Mineral Field Western Australia Kalgoorlie 1:250,000 Sh |
| A52854 | 1997 | Centaur Mining & Exploration Ltd | Woodcutters Dam | 1.4% | Woodcutters Dam, Annual Report for the period 16/10/96 - 15/10/97. [C226/1995] |
| A48504 | 1996 | Wmc Resources Ltd | Scotia | 58% | The Scotia Project (M24/279 and M24/336) Kalgoorlie 1:250 000 Sheet SH51-9 Bardoc 1:100 000 Sheet 3137 Annual |
| A50129 | 1996 | Western Mining Corporation Ltd | Lake Goongarrie | <1% | Annual report for the period 1 October 1995 to 30 September 1996 The Lake Goongarrie Joint Venture Project Exp |
| A45785 | 1995 | Pancontinental Gold Operations Pty Ltd | Scotia Dam | <1% | Annual Report Scotia Project K95/012R E29/131,E24/74, P23/3114-3117,3123,3137-38,P24/3217-3226.2 November 1995 |
| A46340 | 1995 | Western Mining Corporation Ltd | Lake Goongarrie | <1% | Annual report for the period 1 Ocotber 1994 to 30 September 1995 The Lake Goongarrie Joint Venture Project Exp |
| A41326 | 1994 | Dalrymple Resources Nl | North Scotia | 1.9% | Annual report for the period 05/05/93-04/05/94 North Scotia Project E29/162 |
| A41955 | 1994 | Pancontinental Mining Ltd | Scotia Dam | <1% | Scotia Annual Report (M7584) Period ending 30 June 1994 (Report K94/016R for the period 01/07/93-30/06/94) (E2 |
| A43078 | 1994 | Western Mining Corporation Ltd | Lake Goongarrie | <1% | Annual report for the period 7 April 1994 to 30 September 1994 The Lake Goongarrie Joint Venture Project Explo |
| A38606 | 1993 | Pancontinental Mining Ltd | Scotia Dam | <1% | Annual report for the period 16/06/92-15/06/93 Scotia Dam Project E29/131 |
| A35306 | 1992 | Western Mining Corporation Ltd | Scotia | 58% | Technical Report on Scotia Mine Project M24/279,336 P24/2632-2638,2641-2643 for the period 27/08/89-26/08/91 W |
| A36608 | 1992 | Pancontinental Mining Ltd | Scotia Dam | <1% | Scotia Dam E29/131 Annual Report for the year ending 15 June 1992 |
| A29980 | 1990 | Western Mining Corporation Ltd | Scotia Mine | 41% | Technical report on the Scotia Mine Project E24/11; M24/176,279; For The Period 28/08/87 - 10/01/90 |
| A25780 | 1988 | Western Mining Corporation Ltd | Scotia | <1% | Scotia Project, Non-statutory Report: Terminal Report for the period 27th August 1984 to 30th June 1988 , E24 |
| A12201 | 1983 | Western Mining Corporation Ltd | North Scotia | 3.1% | Annual Report North Scotia Mineral Claims 9 December 1981 to 7 December 1982 |
| A10344 | 1981 | Western Mining Corporation Ltd | Ringlock-Scotia | 6.1% | Annual Report on Ringlock-Scotia for the period 21st May, 1980 to 9th December, 1980. |
| A5933 | 1975 | Asarco Australia Ltd | Scotia | <1% | Scotia Project, Annual Report for the period ending 31st July 1975, MC24/1407-1465, 2737-2760 ; MC29/95-96. |
| A38751 | 1753 | Inco Australia Ltd | Eastern Goldfields regional mapping | <1% | Eastern Goldfields regional mapping |
| A50332 | 1753 | Goldfields Exploration Pty Ltd | Scotia | <1% | Annual report Project Scotia Period covered 01/07/1995 to 31/12/1996 Tenements E29/131 E24/74 P274/3109 to P24 |
Doing your homework on this ground? The register summary above tells you the tenement
exists and who holds it. The checks below tell you whether it is clean: what is secured
against it, whether it is meeting its minimum expenditure commitment, what conditions attach
to it, and how long the current holder has actually had it.
Tenure detail Free account
- Current holders & shares
- Holder change history
- Expenditure history
- Conditions & endorsements
- Native title context
- Combined reporting
- Rent status
Tenement intelligence Premium
- Time to expiry
- 5 years · 10 Jan 2032
- At-risk & opportunity signals
- Expenditure compliance
- 5-year track record
- Spend trend & exploration intensity
- Expiry band
- Ownership age
- Dealings, mortgages & caveats
- Transfer history
What does the exploration record say about this ground?
NextMaps reads every WAMEX report over M 24/336 into a referenced prospectivity assessment: the geology, the historical programs, the drill intercepts and geochemistry, and the untested gaps — every claim cited back to its source report. New accounts include a free prospectivity report. Prefer the raw due diligence? The Tenure Pack bundles the full register record, tenure history and spatial datasets for this ground.
Open on the map — full register record About AI reports About Tenure PacksDo you hold M 24/336? Listing is free. A facilitation fee applies only if the ground ends up with a buyer we introduce.
List this tenement
WA Mining Weekly
The week's tenement movements, deals and ground released, free to your inbox.
Tenure data sourced from the DMPE public registers and SLIP WA (© Government of Western Australia, CC BY 4.0), as at 2026-09-26. Compiled by NextMaps. Verify against primary sources before reliance.